We sugarcoat everything!

French macarons, fresh breads and pastries baked every morning, wedding cakes and custom cookie favors made with the best ingredients… Satisfy your sweet tooth with a visit to our bakery.

In Store Bakery

In our bakery, we have…

Something for every day and your special day

Café Pierrot has been baking in Sussex County for over 30 years. Owner Rick Nifenecker had a vision of high quality, delicious baked goods in North Jersey, and the bakery has been pursuing this goal ever since.



What’s better than a macaron? Our seasonal flavors are perfect with your afternoon coffee break, and our custom orders make beautiful weddings favors for your guests.

Custom Cupcakes

When your party isn’t big enough for a custom cake, order fun custom cupcakes instead! Browse our gallery to be inspired for your own party theme.

Cookie Favors

Everyone’s favorite party favor, custom cookies can be fun or elegant to match any theme. Order monogrammed cookies for wedding favors or character cookies for a kids’ party! They’ll all be delicious!

Put the finishing touch on your wedding reception with a cake to remember. Guests will keep talking about cake long after the party’s over, and you’ll be looking forward to that first anniverary!

Gluten Free Bakery Items

Even our gluten-free friends deserve to have a sweet treat! In store we have gluten free macarons and cupcakes, and choose from our menu for any custom creations.

Special Events

Planning a special event? Whether you’re surprising a friend for their birthday, celebrating an anniversary, or planning a bridal shower, our curated cake collection has nearly-custom options to that make the perfect ending to your party.


What People are Saying

“Always Amazing”

“Food is always amazing and packaged so it stays warm and in place when you take home. Easy ordering, pick up, and purchase system. Thank you for making it easy and delicious!.”


“So Special”

“Laura’s attention to detail was so amazing & appreciated, and the meal Rick created was a 20 on the scale of 10!! So good!!! So special!!! So appreciated!!. “


“You made everything simple”

“…. from order to pick up to heating instructions. Thanks so much for helping us make another wonderful holiday meal for our family”



“In a word, the food was exceptional the service in impeccable, and I could not be more happier.”


Recently, our all-butter croissants were featured on the Cooking Channel’s show, Holy and Hungry. We love baking these fresh every morning, and serving our delicious sandwiches on these croissants.

We’re constantly reviewing trends and adding new products to our galleries. Follow the links below to view our wedding cakes, macaron favors, custom cookies, and specialty cakes.  Browse our in-store bakery menu to see what’s baked fresh everyday for our 2 locations.

Email bakery@cafepierrot.com for more information or to start planning your event!